Skip to content
  • Group
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • Careers
  • Services
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Newsfeed
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
Menu
  • Group
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • Careers
  • Services
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Newsfeed
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Group

    Group

    The MARC Group of Companies comprises MARC Ratings, MARC Solutions, MARC Data and MARC Learning.

    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning

    MARC Ratings

    • Rating Guide
    • Rating Process
    • Rating Symbols & Definitions
    • Rating Methodologies
    • Regulatory
    • Lead Managers

    MARC Solutions

    MARC Data

    MARC Learning

    • Careers
    • Careers
  • Services

    Services

    MARC's subsidiaries each provide distinct product offerings and services.

    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights

    Insights

    Find the vital information you need and stay up to date with the latest news from MARC.

    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Latest@MARC
    • MARC in the Media
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR

    Events & CSR

    MARC organises a diverse range of events throughout the year to engage with all stakeholders.

    • MARCares
    • Events
    • MARCares
    • Events
  • Contact Us

    Contact Us

    Let's get the conversation started - Get in touch with us!

    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
MARC Online
Subscribe
Menu
  • Group
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Group
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
Sustainability- Related Assessments
Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
Subscriptions
Sustainability- Related Advisory
Debt Advisory
Analytics Consulting Services
Data Analytics
Credit Reporting
Learning Programme

Credit Ratings & Related Assessments

Sustainability- Related Assessments

Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis

Subscriptions

Sustainability- Related Advisory

Corporate & Debt Restructuring Advisory

Analytics Consulting Services

Data Analytics

Credit Reporting

Learning & Customised Programme

  • Insights
  • Latest@MARC
Corporate

Windfall profit levy (electricity) Order 2008 : Thoroughly thought through?

View Reports

Contacts

Posted Date : 09 Jul 2008

MARC expects the outcome of the Windfall Profit Levy (Electricity) Order 2008 would be, reduced project returns and lowered debt servicing ability on the part of affected independent power producers (IPPs), if implemented. The impact will be uneven across different classes of IPP project debts. Holders of subordinated debt will be affected to a greater extent given the reduced after-tax residual cashflows available for servicing junior debt.

The government's move to impose windfall taxes may have far grave potential implications, in the longer term, on infrastructure debt financings, and for both lenders and borrowers. A key question which arises is whether recent developments signal increased regulatory risk going forward. The willingness of the government to support original arrangements on which project financings rest, from power purchase agreements (PPA) to its tax regime, has always been an important underpinning for the high investment grade ratings assigned to IPPs and their senior bonds.

The introduction of windfall tax now challenges the historical assumption of low regulatory risk for IPP financings and introduces an added element of uncertainty, i.e. the potential erosion of project cashflows due to interim regulatory changes. This risk could equally apply to all other infrastructure concessions. Proposed changes to the tax regime should be considered in the light of its effects on existing project financiers including bondholders and future investor behaviour. MARC views the windfall tax regime as punitive in nature as it would have the effect of penalizing efficient IPPs. Of greater concern from a rating perspective is the transfer of the financial effects of the punitive elements to bondholders, and consequently, the potential downward re-rating of existing bonds.

MARC believes that implementation of the windfall tax will detract from the original objective of power sector privatization, i.e. to promote and reward efficiency. MARC foresees that IPP may start engaging tax optimization strategies rather than striving for operational efficiency to avoid exceeding the 9% benchmark of return on asset, defined as PBIT (profit before interest & tax) over fixed assets, to avoid the costly 30% windfall levy. MARC believes the IPPs may be motivated to circumvent the windfall levy by revaluing their power plant assets on a replacement cost method, especially now that current material, engineering and contract prices are much higher.

In the overall scheme of things, while we acknowledge the government’s need to address its fiscal deficit under the current scenario of moderating economic growth, the windfall tax may not be the most appropriate fiscal tool. Nonetheless, MARC believes sound decision will ultimately prevail with respect to the proposed implementation of the windfall tax. 

You May Also Like To Read

See All
Events

MARC to host economic discourse

6 December, 2022

Ratings

Banking Sector Insights - Weathering the Headwinds

1 December, 2022

Ratings

MARC Issues Sector Report On Automotive Industry

1 December, 2022

See All

Let’s get started.

Subscribe to our mailing list today

Subscribe Now
Group
  • About MARC
  • Leadership
  • Investor Relations
  • Notable Issuances
  • Careers
Regulatory
  • Rating Reviews Summary
  • List of Defaults
  • List of Credit Ratings Published
  • List of Entities on Rating Watch
Services
  • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
  • Sustainability-Related Assessments
  • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
  • Sustainability-Related Advisory
  • Corporate & Debt Restructuring Advisory
  • Subscriptions
  • Analytics Consulting Services
  • Data Analytics
  • Credit Reporting
  • Learning & Customised Programmes
Subsidaries
  • MARC Ratings
  • MARC Learning
  • MARC Data
  • MARC Solutions
Insights
  • Rating Announcements
  • Research & Analysis
  • Views
  • Latest@MARC
  • MARC in the Media
Events
  • Corporate Events
  • Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
  • Advertise with MARC
Contact Us
  • Contact Us
  • Service Level Feedback Form
  • Publication Feedback Form
  • Whistleblowing
  • Group
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • Careers
  • Services
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Newsfeed
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Notice
Copyright Notice
Whistleblowing
PDPA Notice
© 2023 Malaysian Rating Corporation Berhad. All rights reserved.
Facebook Twitter Linkedin

Join MARC Mailing List

I would like to subscribe this mailing list. Please tick whichever is applicable

I agree/ do not agree (please tick whichever is applicable) to receive future events, conferences or marketing materials from MARC. *

Privacy Notice *

Declaration *