Skip to content
  • Group
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • Careers
  • Services
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Newsfeed
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
Menu
  • Group
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • Careers
  • Services
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Newsfeed
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Group

    Group

    The MARC Group of Companies comprises MARC Ratings, MARC Solutions, MARC Data and MARC Learning.

    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning

    MARC Ratings

    • Rating Guide
    • Rating Process
    • Rating Symbols & Definitions
    • Rating Methodologies
    • Regulatory
    • Lead Managers

    MARC Solutions

    MARC Data

    MARC Learning

    • Careers
    • Careers
  • Services

    Services

    MARC's subsidiaries each provide distinct product offerings and services.

    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights

    Insights

    Find the vital information you need and stay up to date with the latest news from MARC.

    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Latest@MARC
    • MARC in the Media
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR

    Events & CSR

    MARC organises a diverse range of events throughout the year to engage with all stakeholders.

    • MARCares
    • Events
    • MARCares
    • Events
  • Contact Us

    Contact Us

    Let's get the conversation started - Get in touch with us!

    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
MARC Online
Subscribe
Menu
  • Group
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Group
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
Sustainability- Related Assessments
Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
Subscriptions
Sustainability- Related Advisory
Debt Advisory
Analytics Consulting Services
Data Analytics
Credit Reporting
Learning Programme
  • Insights
  • Views
  • Addressing the country’s budget and current account concerns
Economic Views

Addressing the country’s budget and current account concerns

6 May 2019

View Report

Contacts

Malaysia’s equity market experienced an outflow of foreign capital to the tune of RM1.3 billion in the first quarter of 2019. The bond market was spared during this period, however, registering net foreign inflows for the first time since December 2018.

But a spate of news relating to the possible exclusion of Malaysia from the FTSE-Russell World Government Bond Index could limit the inflows in the near term. The pressure was reflected in the benchmark 10-year Malaysian Government Securities (MGS) yield, which spiked by 12 basis points in the third week of April. All of a sudden, there is renewed interest in the country’s pertinent macroeconomic issues.

Adding to the pressure on the ringgit is the possibility of Bank Negara adjusting the policy rate downwards, judging from the dovishness of its recent Monetary Policy Committee statement. The market has to a certain extent priced in this possible reduction. Analysts’ comments on the government’s fiscal position and current account (of the balance of payments) have also raised some anxiety in the financial market over Malaysia’s macro landscape. This is hardly surprising, as investors continue to focus on the government’s financial health and the country’s shrinking savings-investment gap (or current account).

While a bumpy ride looks imminent, we would do well to step back and examine the broader picture. In general, economists are aware of the possible repercussions if the two economic evils, i.e. budget and current account deficits, were to emerge simultaneously (by the way, Malaysia registered a still-healthy current account surplus equivalent to 2.4 percent of gross national income (GNI) in 2018, although this is lower than the past few years). The so-called ‘twin deficit’ tends to induce sudden capital outflows and weigh on countries’ currencies. A case in point: both the Indonesian rupiah and Indian rupee have been on investors’ watchlist for some time. Whenever these countries’ budgetary and current account positions deteriorate, their currencies will get hammered.

One point is worth mentioning. From a theoretical point of view, there is a connection between budgetary and current account gaps. Those familiar with the national accounting identity (i.e. Economics 101) can easily prove this relationship mathematically. But a simple explanation for the man on-the-street would be as follows: budget deficits, normally the result of higher government spending, pushes up a country’s aggregate demand. This, in turn, leads to rising interest rates. Under a flexible exchange rate regime, a positive interest rate differential vis-à-vis the rest of the world would induce capital inflows into the country. This strengthens its exchange rate but would lead to a deterioration in its current account balance, as the country’s exports become more expensive and thus less competitive on the international market (this is basically the story of the Mundell-Fleming model, a standard economic model in the study of international economics).

Having said this, however, many countries experiencing budget deficits do not incur current account deficits. In the case of Malaysia, for example, budget deficits incurred since 1998 were accompanied by current account surpluses instead. However, the recent concern of investors is the declining trend of Malaysia’s current account surpluses as a percentage of GNI in the past few years.

It is also worth noting that from a theoretical perspective, a budget deficit on its own is not the real economic evil. The deficit only represents an excess of spending over revenue. More important are the reasons for this, i.e. was the spending for the meaningful generation of economic activity, or merely for the sake of spending (i.e. white-elephant projects)? Or has the country failed to generate sufficient revenue?

Of greater importance is the way the deficit is financed. In some parts of the world, deficits are financed through money printing. In such cases, inflationary pressure builds up and when prices get out of control, capital flight will occur. This is what investors fear the most. On the other hand, financing the deficit through bond issuances is not inflationary. However, it tends to exert upward pressure on interest rates, which, if too excessive, will impact investments.

That said, there are a few points worth mentioning about Malaysia’s budget deficits. One of the concerns is derived from the fact that the negative budget gap has been around for two decades since the Asian Financial Crisis in the late-1990s. Therefore, it is quite normal for the investor fraternity to wonder when it will cease to exist, and whether it will be a real drag on the economy going forward.

A look at Malaysia’s budgetary history shows that the country has experienced many deficit years since 1970. The only years that Malaysia experienced budgetary surpluses were between 1993 and 1997 (only five years). At least in the Malaysian case, the deficits had not resulted in material macroeconomic disasters. Of course, moving to a balanced budget as envisioned by the government would be a plus point for the economy.

Second, raising funds to finance fiscal deficits in Malaysia has never been a real issue. Malaysian government bonds are in demand, as evidenced by decent bid-to-cover ratios (essentially how many times the bonds are oversubscribed) over the years. Past records show that MGS and Government Investment Issue (GII) issuances were comfortably absorbed by the market.

On another note, Malaysia’s shrinking current account surpluses are a concern, especially when global trade activity is softening. Lower trade surpluses exert pressure on the current account balance, causing the surpluses to shrink to 2.4% of GNI in 2018 from 11.2% in 2011. But slower investment growth will also ease some of the pressure on the current account balance. This is because the current account balance also reflects the country’s savings-investment gap. A slightly lower investment (relative to savings) will be positive for the current account balance in the near term. Hence, rationalising (or spacing out) some of the mega projects will ease concerns over the shrinking current account surpluses for Malaysia. Of course, this has to be balanced by the overall benefits of these investments.

Malaysia had experienced a brief period of twin deficits in the 1990s. However, that was when the country’s investment ratio was way above 40 per cent of gross domestic product. Even then, the country managed to wheel out of it by spacing out its projects. This time around, the economic landscape is different. Investment ratios are nowhere around that level, whilst a more diversified export market provides an important buffer for Malaysia’s trade performance.

This article was published in The Edge Malaysia Weekly dated May 6, 2019 – May 12, 2019.

Related Report

Read More

Related Issues

Read More

Related News

Read More

You May Also Like To Read

See All
Fixed-Income Views

MARC Ratings publishes 2022 annual corporate default and ratings transition study

28 March 2023

Fixed-Income Views

Foreigners net buyers of ringgit bonds in January

22 February 2023

Fixed-Income Views

Local govvies extended gains in December

9 February 2023

See All

Let’s get started.

Subscribe to our mailing list today

Subscribe Now
Group
  • About MARC
  • Leadership
  • Investor Relations
  • Notable Issuances
  • Careers
Regulatory
  • Rating Reviews Summary
  • List of Defaults
  • List of Credit Ratings Published
  • List of Entities on Rating Watch
Services
  • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
  • Sustainability-Related Assessments
  • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
  • Sustainability-Related Advisory
  • Corporate & Debt Restructuring Advisory
  • Subscriptions
  • Analytics Consulting Services
  • Data Analytics
  • Credit Reporting
  • Learning & Customised Programmes
Subsidaries
  • MARC Ratings
  • MARC Learning
  • MARC Data
  • MARC Solutions
Insights
  • Rating Announcements
  • Research & Analysis
  • Views
  • Latest@MARC
  • MARC in the Media
Events
  • Corporate Events
  • Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
  • Advertise with MARC
Contact Us
  • Contact Us
  • Service Level Feedback Form
  • Publication Feedback Form
  • Whistleblowing
  • Group
    • About MARC
    • Leadership
    • Investor Relations
    • Notable Issuances
    • MARC Ratings
    • MARC Solutions
    • MARC Data
    • MARC Learning
    • Careers
  • Services
    • Credit Ratings & Related Assessments
    • Sustainability-Related Assessments
    • Economic & Fixed-Income Analysis
    • Sustainability-Related Advisory
    • Debt Advisory
    • Analytics Consulting Services
    • Subscriptions
    • Data Analytics
    • Credit Reporting
    • Learning Programmes
  • Insights
    • Rating Announcements
    • Research & Analysis
    • Views
    • MARC in the Media
    • Newsfeed
    • Latest@MARC
  • Events & CSR
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Service Level Feedback Form
    • Publication Feedback Form
    • Whistleblowing
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Notice
Copyright Notice
Whistleblowing
PDPA Notice
© 2023 Malaysian Rating Corporation Berhad. All rights reserved.
Facebook Twitter Linkedin

Join MARC Mailing List

I would like to subscribe this mailing list. Please tick whichever is applicable

I agree/ do not agree (please tick whichever is applicable) to receive future events, conferences or marketing materials from MARC. *

Privacy Notice *

Declaration *